I remember using this when it first came out in a sample and I loved it. I finally bought it years later this past March and I have never had a worse mascara. At first it starts to look great–if you can avoid it from clumping to the point where instead of beautiful lashes you only have four spikes–but it quickly starts to melt off your face. Literally. It will flake off and pool under your eyes and then it seems to like melt into your skin and leave this weird smeared line as if you put eyeliner on all wrong and tried to rub it off. I\’ve heard the waterproof one is better, but I don\’t have the patience to try it.