Rating 4 stars only because I believe the formula texture changes by shade. I own Lolita and Exorcism, and noticed the difference. I bought both at Sephora so there\’s no chance one\’s a fake or anything like that. I noticed Exorcism is kind of drying and slightly patchy in color. It did work slightly better and more smoothly when I used a lip moisturizer under it. Lolita is absolutely smooth and feels wonderful. They both don\’t transfer and are seriously everlasting. I had tried Echo inside Sephora and it was also a bit dry, so I think maybe the darker shades are dry compared to the lighter shades.