I wear a cat eye just about everyday and I have been using a drugstore waterproof liquid liner ever since high school. I bought this product in black and it wasn\’t as dark as I expected and it isn\’t long wearing. Now, I am darker in complexion, however for $20 this just isn\’t worth it. I get better results with my $3.99 liquid liner and it lasts longer than my 12 hour shift. I love KVD but this product is a miss.