This lives up to both the negative and positive reviews. When i first opened the tube it did just what it did with others. It is filled with way too much air, and there will also be an oily residue when first squeezed. Also be aware as mine literally shot out a bit of product when squeezed. i got rid of a bit of the liquid by squishing it a bit in the tube. When i first tried it on my hand in the store it really was difficult to get off, but on my eyes it did seem to smudge at the end of the day though it does glides on smoothly. I\’m sure this is because i have oily skin so if you have dry skin it will probably stay on longer. Overall a good product the only downfall for me was first opening it.