I received this in my Play! box. It applied nicely, separating and thickening my lashes. I did comb through with a fan brush, but the clumping was minimal even before I did so. Unfortunately, the flaking and fallout started before I even left the house and continued all day until i removed it. Like other reviewers mentioned, this does have a scent, but it surprisingly did not irritate my normally sensitive eyes. If this had better staying power, I would recommend it.