I like the idea of the formula in theory but it hurt my eyes and had fallout. Also the size of the wand and the packaging are a complete fail.
I really hoped so I tried just the mascara. No luck, it got in my eyes after application by wandering after it dried so it was like sand in my eyes. I even used clear mascara and applied this after and it still had horrible fallout. I have fine textured skin that is very pale so it shows up. This all makes me give one star.
Bobbi Brown and her company should rework this formula.