I thought I had finally found the perfect every day lipstick! It\’s the perfect neutral for me, soft and hydrating, beautiful, flattering. But, it breaks off ! It\’s so soft that even when new you have to make sure you have only roll up a tiny bit. I resorted to using a lip brush to dig it out because I love the color so much. I reluctantly decided to try again just to be sure before abandoning this seeming perfect lipstick for ever. And, yes, the second one broke off too.